In a recent referendum, the voters in Switzerland called for a ban on the construction of new minarets in the country. This is not a ban on new mosques, but rather on those tall towers called “minarets” which accompany almost every mosque. It is from the top of a minaret that a Muslim religious leader calls for the five daily prayers required of all Muslims, although today these “calls” are usually done with loudspeakers.
I have found most of the reactions to this vote to be deplorable. The very title of this article, “Europe unites to deplore Swiss ban on minarets“, almost says it all. Who is uniting? Certainly not those European Swiss voters. Certainly not the majority of citizens in other European countries. Well, that article itself says it all when it reports that “The Swiss and European establishment united today in deploring yesterday’s decision by Swiss voters”. Yes, it is the “establishment” that is uniting, and another word for the “establishment” is the word “elites”. The “elite”, you see, know better than you do. From the various reports on this matter, it turns out that nearly all of the “elites” who are speaking out against this ban belong to center and left-of-center political parties. Almost no one from a “right-wing” party is critizing this ban. In fact, as reported in that referenced article:
France’s far right National Front welcomed the outcome, saying that the “elites should stop denying the aspirations and fears of the European people, who, without opposing religious freedom, reject ostentatious signs that political-religious Muslim groups want to impose.” The French center-right party, the Union for a Popular Majority, said that the vote showed the degree to which radical Islam was alarming Europe’s citizens.
Note the use of the word “elites” in that paragraph. Well, surely everyone knows that the political parties on the right, especially on the far right such as the French National Front, are almost as bad as Nazis. They must be ignored at the very least. (Yeh, right.)
The politically-correct way to look at this vote was expressed by Le Temps, Geneva’s establishment newspaper, when it said: “The vote was inspired by fear, fantasies and ignorance.” Damage to the country’s international standing would be spectacular, it said. “Vengeance, boycotts, retaliation … this clash with Islam could cost dearly.” Yeh, right. You jackasses. There already is a clash with Islam in Western Europe! Even before 9/11 there were terrorists bombings in France by Muslim extremists which cost lives. After 9/11 there were the deadly bombings in Spain and Great Britain, bombings carried out by Muslims. To say that the “The vote was inspired by fear, fantasies and ignorance” is not only false, but also an abominable and perhaps cowardly statement. It is true that at least some of the votes were inspired by fear. But this fear was justified. The votes were definitely not inspired by “fantasies” and “ignorance”. If anyone suffers from fantasies and ignorance in this matter, it is in fact the so-called “elites” or the “establishment”. It frightens me that those political leaders do not see that, or, if they do see it, they hide it out of cowardice.
In the early 1960′s I spent over two years in Europe as an enlisted man in the United States Army, mostly in France. I do not remember seeing any Muslims. During the past 10 years I have visited Europe four times as a tourist, spending a total of over two months in France, England, Belgium, Holland and Luxembourg. This time I saw a fair amount of Muslims. I have some French friends, and I read French and speak enough French to get by. I often read the news about Europe on the Internet, to include reading news on the web sites of French newspapers. I thus know first-hand how many ordinary people in Europe feel about the growing population of Muslims in Europe, and the growing political influence of Islam in Europe. One of my French friends, the assistant mayor of a French village, told me that the next time I visit there will probably be a mosque in their village. He was speaking sarcastically, but there was a kernel of truth in his statement. It is important to realize that, at least in France, the fear and/or distrust of Muslims is not based on the fact that they happen not to be Christians. Instead it is based on the fact that the Muslim immigrants in France cling to their Muslim culture, a culture which disdains the secularism in France, a culture which clings to the Islam religion and its practices and which encourages extremism, at least to some extent. Last but not least, most Muslims are in favor of sharia law. The replacement of even any part of European laws by sharia laws would be not only harmful, but an absolute disgrace to the advances made by western civilization. (If it were up to me, I would not only ban minarets, I would also ban mosques.)